Frank Calls Late VAR Decision a ‘Clear Error’
Tottenham Hotspur manager Thomas Frank was left furious after a late VAR intervention handed Newcastle United a controversial penalty in a dramatic 2-2 draw at St James’ Park.
The incident came in the 86th minute with the score level at 1-1. While preparing to defend a corner, Spurs midfielder Rodrigo Bentancur tangled with Newcastle defender Dan Burn, with both players falling to the ground in what appeared to be a routine physical challenge. Referee Thomas Bramall initially allowed play to continue.
However, VAR advised the referee to review the incident, claiming Bentancur had committed a holding offence without attempting to play the ball. After visiting the pitchside monitor, Bramall overturned his original decision and awarded the penalty.
Anthony Gordon successfully converted from the spot, but Cristian Romero produced a spectacular 95th-minute overhead kick to rescue a point for Tottenham.
Frank was furious with the VAR intervention, insisting the original on-field decision was correct.
“It was an absolute mistake from the VAR,” Frank said.
“The referee nailed it on the pitch, and VAR should only intervene if it’s clear and obvious — this was not.”
Even some Newcastle staff privately admitted it was soft, according to Frank.
Why VAR Awarded the Penalty
The PGMOL later explained that the decision was made because Bentancur “clearly does not look at the ball” and committed a holding offence that impacted Burn’s ability to challenge.
This explanation sparked debate among pundits and fans, especially considering similar tussles commonly happen at set-pieces.
Newcastle manager Eddie Howe also offered a balanced reaction after seeing the replay for the first time.
“The defender isn’t looking at the ball at all… it’s probably the right call,” Howe said.
Pundits Demand Consistency
Former players and analysts were vocal in their criticism.
Izzy Christiansen argued that giving penalties for such moments could lead to “a penalty every game,” while Micah Richards pointed out that there wasn’t enough sustained holding for such a major call.
Jamie Redknapp added that there must be a clear, consistent threshold:
“If that’s the standard going forward, fine — but we want consistency.”
Despite the controversy, Spurs will feel relieved that Romero’s late strike earned them a valuable point, even if the spotlight remains firmly on VAR.
Also Read: Kendall’s Dream Night Shines as Young Midfielder Scores First England Goal